
I keep coming back to a line from the excellent David Mamet film House of Games (1987):
âYou canât make someone into a whore if she werenât a whore to begin with.â
Itâs brutal. Misogynistic.
Butâis there something in it worth wrestling with?
Do people turn bad, or were they always that way?
Do we become ourselves, or merely reveal ourselves?
Essentialists believe people are born a certain wayâgood or bad, strong or weak, prone to vice or virtueâand that circumstances simply bring those qualities to the surface. Itâs an old idea. Plato touched on it. Many fundamentalist Christians lean heavily toward essentialist thinking.
Take Original Sin (from St. Augustine): the belief that all humans are born sinful because of Adam and Eveâs transgression. Thatâs essentialism. Youâre born flawed.
But that view ignores the shaping force of environment, trauma, and opportunity.
The counterpoint is Social Constructivism: the idea that people become who they are through experienceâfamily, culture, power structures. In this view, a person âturns badâ because theyâre mistreated, cornered, or left with no other option.
A Constructivist would say Mametâs character is ignoring context: the pressures, abuses, and systems that push people into choices they wouldnât otherwise make.
Iâm leaning toward âprobably both.â
Itâs an easy way out, sureâbut most honest thinking lives in the gray space.
People have tendencies. But theyâre also shaped.
A person may have a seed of greed, cruelty, or just raw survival instinctâbut itâs the soil of their experience that allows it to grow⌠or wither.
Recently, I showed my students in Advanced Script Analysis class the Ingmar Bergman film Shame (1968). Thereâs only one film Iâve seen more times than Shame â Airplane! (1980).
In Shame, Janâplayed by Max von Sydowâbegins as a passive artist, a former musician living in rural exile with his wife Eva (Liv Ullmann), trying to stay uninvolved in a civil war.
He doesnât want to take sides. Heâs withdrawn. Childlike.
You could call him fragile, idealistic, or cowardlyâdepending on your view of the world.
No, heâs not admirable. But heâs far from a monster.
He wants safety without responsibility. You get the sense heâs been coddled by privilege and culture.
Then the war gets closer.
Soldiers arrive. Their home is raided. Theyâre interrogated, violated, humiliated.
Jan can no longer hide behind neutrality.
And he transforms.
First, he starts making morally questionable choices to survive. He kills. He lies. He trades favors.
Then he starts blaming Eva. Becomes controlling. Cruel.
By the end, heâs a cold, paranoid figureâunrecognizable from the man we met.

I keep thinking:
How much pressure does it take to crack a personality?
And what leaks out when it does?
If you take the Essentialist view, you could argue Jan was always weak and self-serving. The war didnât change himâit stripped away the polite mask.
His early passivity wasnât idealism. It was cowardice.
His art? A shield.
Underneath, he was already a narcissistic survivalist.
The war just gave that part of him permission.
But if youâre a Constructivist, then the cold, cruel world did this to him.
Trauma warped him.
Humiliation shattered his identity.
War turned a gentle man into something brutalânot because he always was that way, but because people adapt, sometimes horribly.
This view is more tragicâand arguably more in line with Bergmanâs own.
He doesnât condemn Jan. He shows how ordinary people fracture under pressure.
But with all my love and respect for Bergman, Iâm not sure I agree.
Maybe the real question isnât:
Was he bad? Or made bad?
But:
What part of him was waiting for permission to emerge?
Jean-Jacques Rousseau believed in the ânoble savageââthat weâre born good, and society corrupts us.
John Locke thought weâre born neutral (tabula rasa), and shaped entirely by experience.
I think they both erred.
Yes, their arguments are elegant. Both are hopeful in their own way.
But both flatten the terrifying complexity of being human.
Iâve seen siblings raised with the same values become oppositesâone generous, one exploitative.
Iâve seen people with every advantage grow bitter and cruel.
And Iâve seen people from violent, unstable beginnings grow into the gentlest, most stable souls I know.




There are temperaments, instincts, shadows, and hungers that seem baked inâfucking mysteriously so (pardon my Danish).
Ask anyone whoâs worked with childrenâor adults in crisisâand theyâll tell you:
Weâre capable of selfishness, cruelty, manipulation before any system teaches it.
Yes, society distorts us.
But it also restrains us.
It teaches empathy. Delays gratification. Channels chaos.
If we were blank slates, experience would explain everything.
It doesnât.
Steven Pinker wrote a whole book about this: The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature.
But hereâs where I land:
Maybe weâre neither blank nor good.
Maybe weâre loaded decks, full of conflicting cards.
We have instincts for cooperation and conquest.
We carry seeds of gentleness and aggression.
What we become depends on which parts get nourished, triggered, or given permission.
Walt Whitman was right.
Do I contradict myself?
Very well then I contradict myself,
(I am large, I contain multitudes.)
And so was Zimmy. Come to think of itâZimmy has always been right.
Pink petal-pushers, red blue jeans
All the pretty maids, and all the old queens
All the old queens from all my past lives
I carry four pistols and two large knives
Iâm a man of contradictions, Iâm a man of many moods
I contain multitudes.
đ What do you think?
Are we forged by experienceâor revealed by it?
What part of you might still be waiting for permission to emerge?
Thanks for reading and being a subscriber. You support makes me a better person.
âTil next time.
ak






Interesting post. Itâs the age old nature vs. nurture debate. - It sounds like a cop out, but I do believe itâs a combination of both. Nothing exists in isolation. Itâs yin & yang. We are complex creatures with a multitude of possibilities.
I'd like to believe we all begin with a blank slate. But, our biology still not greatly understood. Endorphins, genetics, schooling, parents, siblings, aunts, uncles, mates, enemies, and so much more of the unknown which could possibly play a part in all of this. Nature vs nurture?