6 Comments
User's avatar
Janet Brown's avatar

A long time ago someone asked me why I didn't carry a camera with me when I traveled. I said if I took a picture I owned the place I looked at but if I wrote about it, it owned me. Glib but in some ways true. You make me want to read both Sontag and Berger and you make me rethink my aversion to blending images and words.

Framing-the-Story's avatar

Thanks for your comment. Yes, the books are worth reading and rereading.

without force or haste's avatar

For me they both only half get to an understanding about the relationship between pictures and words although that is not to demean their efforts. I think this article is well put together. Many thanks

Framing-the-Story's avatar

Thank you for reading and commenting.

Glen’s Pictures and Posts's avatar

Interesting piece that you've written here. If asked, I think I'd say I leaned more toward the Berger side of things...

søren k. harbel's avatar

Can we please forget and burn the Sontag book? She freely admitted that after she met Annie Leibovitz and actually saw and understood what photography is all about, she would not have written what she did. It is time to forget this fire-starter and move on. Sorry, no offence but it is a useless text.